Point of View Middle School: The Who’s Telling It? Routine That Works

Ask a class who is telling a story and you will get the main character’s name, the author’s name, and once — memorably — “the book.” Point of view questions go wrong before they start because students answer from memory of the plot instead of evidence about the telling. They know what happened. They have not stopped to ask who is doing the telling, or what that choice hides from them.

The fix is a short routine that runs the same way on fiction and nonfiction alike: find the narrator, check the pronouns, then ask what the reader cannot know.

Step 1: Find the narrator before you name the point of view.

Ban the labels for the first minute. No “first person” or “third person” until a student can point to the voice actually telling the text. Have students underline the first sentence where the narrator reveals themselves and read it aloud. A narrator who says “I had never been so embarrassed” is inside the story. A narrator who watches from outside is not, no matter whose name appears most often on the page.

Step 2: Run the pronoun check.

Pronouns are the fastest honest evidence students have. I, me, and we inside the narration mean first person. He, she, and they with no narrator inside the scene mean third person. This sits right beside the prove-it routine I use for author’s purpose: a point-of-view answer without a pronoun or a quoted line underneath it is a guess, and guesses do not earn points. Require the evidence first, then the label.

Step 3: Ask what the reader cannot know.

This is the question that separates third-person limited from third-person omniscient, and it is the one students skip. If the narrator can enter only one character’s thoughts, the reader is locked out of everyone else’s — say that plainly. “Whose thoughts can we read? Whose can’t we?” Two questions, answered from the text, settle arguments that vocabulary definitions never do. It also explains why a limited narrator can surprise us: the surprise was hidden in a head we could not enter.

Step 4: In nonfiction, follow the point of view to the loaded words.

Point of view is not only a fiction skill. A first-person account, a biography, and a news report on the same event tell three different stories, and the narrator’s position shapes which details get included and which words carry a charge. Have students find one loaded word and one detail another narrator would have left out. That is where point of view stops being a label and starts being a reading skill — the same habit behind the clue-plus-connection routine I use for making inferences, because what a narrator withholds is exactly what a reader has to infer.

Step 5: Check it with a thirty-second switch.

End with a rewrite, not a quiz. Students take one paragraph and retell it from a different point of view: the other character, a third-person narrator, the person who only watched. If their rewrite does not change what the reader knows, they have not understood the original yet — and now you know it in thirty seconds instead of on Friday’s test. Sort the misses the same way: wrong narrator, no pronoun evidence, or missed what the reader could not know. Three piles, three short fixes.

Find the narrator, prove it with pronouns, and ask what the reader cannot know. Run it on every text for two weeks and point of view stops being the question students guess on — it becomes the first thing they check.

Related resources from the store:

Get Your FREE Tier 2 Intervention Sampler Pack — Grades 6–8

Teaching Tier 2 intervention in grades 6–8?

Get the free 8-page Tier 2 Sampler — diagnostic probes from four full packs, with answer keys — plus occasional intervention tips and new-pack news.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top